The Grammar of Bihar · Part 8 of 8
Why Bihar’s political order has outlasted every leader, alliance and reform that promised to change it, and why it has proved so hard to break.

The first instinct
On 15 April 2026, Samrat Choudhary took the oath as chief minister of Bihar. It was a genuine break with the past. For the first time in the state’s history, the chair belonged to the BJP, and the man who had held it for nearly two decades had left for the Rajya Sabha. Commentators spoke of a new era.
Two days later, the new chief minister sat down at his official residence and began hearing petitions from the public in person. He had revived the Janata Darbar, the weekly people’s court that Nitish Kumar had made his signature in 2006, the queue of the hopeful in which, in its early years, fewer than one complaint in ten was ever resolved. A new party, a new leader, a new era, and the first instinct was to restore the oldest ritual of attention in Bihar’s politics.
There is nothing sinister in this. Choudhary was doing what any sensible politician in Bihar would do: giving the people what they had learned to value most, which is to be seen by the most powerful man in the state. But the scene captures the question this series has been circling. Bihar has changed chief ministers, parties, alliances and slogans many times over. It has abolished zamindari, reserved half its village councils for women, counted its castes, banned liquor and held an election without a single repoll. Through all of it, the underlying pattern has held. What is holding it in place?
Two publics
In 1975, the Nigerian sociologist Peter Ekeh published an essay that explains a great deal about Bihar, though he never wrote a word about it. Ekeh argued that colonial rule left many societies with two publics rather than one. The first, which he called the primordial public, is the world of kin, clan and community: a moral world, to which one owes duty, loyalty and help. The second, the civic public, is the world of the state: an amoral world, built by outsiders, from which one extracts whatever one can on behalf of the first. In such a society, a man who takes from the state to give to his kin is not a thief. He is a good son. The man who fails his kin to protect the state’s treasury is the one who has done wrong.
Bihar’s history could have been written to illustrate the theory. For a century and a half after 1793, the state reached the Bihari peasant as a zamindar’s rent collector. After independence, the institutions that should have replaced it were captured, office by office, by whichever caste coalition held power, and were experienced by everyone else as someone else’s property. And Bihar’s two great moral moments of the twentieth century were both acts of righteous defiance against the state. In 1917, Gandhi went to Champaran and refused an order to leave the district, and India learned that breaking an unjust law could be a duty. In 1974, Jayaprakash Narayan led the students of Patna against a government he called corrupt, in a movement that ended in the Emergency. Bihar’s moral heroes were not the builders of the state. They were its defiers.
So the moral anchor that this series has found again and again, fierce at close range in the family, the caste and the Chhath fast, never reached the state. That single fact explains much of what came before. A leader who bends the state for “us” breaks no rule that his voters hold sacred. A party that fields a strongman is offering a protector for the primordial public against the indifference of the civic one. A government that rewrites a prison rule to please a community is doing, in the eyes of that community, exactly what a government is for.
No clean accuser
Accountability is not only a matter of rules and courts. It also needs someone with the standing to say, credibly, that a wrong has been done: an opposition untainted by the same sin, a newspaper the public trusts, a movement whose own hands are clean. Condemnation is a kind of currency too, and it is only worth something if the person spending it has not been caught doing the same thing.
In Bihar, that currency has been debased on every side. The party that called Nitish Kumar a turncoat took him back. The party he left had itself been his partner, his rival and his partner again. Both camps put their names to Anant Singh’s candidacy in successive elections. The alliance that campaigned against Jungle Raj supplied most of the assembly’s members facing serious charges; the alliance accused of Jungle Raj had the higher share of accused members per seat. Even Jan Suraaj, which presented itself as the clean alternative, had fielded candidates facing serious criminal charges in three of the four by-elections it contested in 2024.
When everyone is compromised, every accusation can be answered with a counter-accusation, and usually is. A charge of opportunism meets a list of the accuser’s own reversals. A charge of criminality meets a list of the accuser’s own candidates. The result is not that wrongdoing goes unnoticed. Bihar notices everything. It is that noticing no longer carries any force, because every accuser can be reminded, within the hour, of his own record.
The price of moving first
Imagine a single village in which every family agreed, tomorrow, to stop backing strongmen, to stop paying for access, to stop bowing to men they fear and to vote only on the record. If everyone did it at once, everyone would be better off: a state that worked would serve them more reliably than any patron ever has. But consider the first family to try it alone. It gives up its protector, its connection at the police station, its place in the queue for the MLA’s attention. Its neighbours keep theirs. The family that moves first does not reform the village. It simply becomes the weakest family in it.
Economists call this a collective action problem, and Bihar is caught in one of the purest forms of it. In 1965 the economist Mancur Olson explained why such traps are so durable. The benefits of reform are spread thinly across millions of people, none of whom gains enough personally to bear the cost of organising. The benefits of the existing arrangement are concentrated in a few hands, the patrons, brokers and strongmen, each of whom has every reason to defend it. Small, concentrated interests organise easily. Large, diffuse ones almost never do.
This is why moral exhortation fails in Bihar, and why it has always failed. Telling people to stop behaving in ways that keep them alive is not a programme of reform. Every actor in this series, from the brothers on the ridge to the minister in Mokama, is doing what makes sense given what everyone else is doing. The lock is not made of bad intentions. It is made of reasonable ones, interlocked.
The valve and the sponge
Two further features make the lock unusually stable. The first is a valve. Every year, Bihar exports a share of the people most able to demand change: the educated, the ambitious, the restless, and disproportionately those with the means to go far. By the state’s own count, about 46 lakh Biharis work in other states and more than two lakh abroad. Their remittances keep millions of households afloat. Their absence keeps the pressure inside the system from ever building to breaking point. Hirschman observed that exit and voice are substitutes: the easier it is to leave, the less people fight to change what they leave behind. Bihar has made leaving easy and changing hard.
The second is a sponge. Bihar’s political order has a remarkable capacity to absorb reforms and return them in a form it can live with. Zamindari was abolished, and the land stayed where it was. A land reform commission was appointed, reported, and shelved. Half the village councils were reserved for women, and their husbands began running them. A caste survey was meant to bring justice to the most backward, and it gave every community a new number to bargain with. An election was fought against the memory of Jungle Raj, and the alliance doing the campaigning supplied most of the accused members of the new assembly. A newcomer promised a cleaner politics, and in 2025 won no seats at all. Each reform was real. Each was absorbed.
The valve removes the people most likely to push. The sponge soaks up whatever pushing gets done. Together with the two publics, the missing accuser and the trap, they explain why an order that almost no one would design on purpose has survived every attempt to redesign it.
What the lock does not explain
An argument this sweeping owes its readers an account of its limits. This series has described a pattern, not a people. It explains why the average incentive in Bihar points towards compromise; it does not explain away the many Biharis who refuse anyway. They pay the price of moving first, and they are everywhere once one looks.
They include the RTI activist from Buxar who used the Right to Information to reveal that fewer than one in ten complaints at the chief minister’s own darbar had been resolved. They include Uma Devi, who took a state government to the Supreme Court over her murdered husband’s killer. They include the women who stood up in a Patna hall in 2015 and demanded that liquor be banned, and the voters of Danapur who rejected a jailed strongman by more than 29,000 votes. They include the officials who will not take the envelope, the teachers who show up, the journalists who keep counting. None of them changed the system alone. All of them prove that it is a system, not a destiny.
The record of the last few years is not all of a piece either. The share of Bihar’s MLAs facing criminal cases fell from 68 per cent in 2020 to 53 per cent in 2025. An election that once needed hundreds of repolls passed without one. Women now vote in greater numbers than men, and nine in ten of them now have a bank account they use themselves. A liquor ban demanded by women appears to have prevented millions of cases of violence against them. And in August 2026, the newcomer who had won nothing a year earlier took Bankipur, a seat the BJP had held since 1995, by more than 19,000 votes. None of this has broken the lock. All of it is happening inside it.
And Bihar is not alone. Much of what this series has described can be found across the Gangetic plain, and other states outdo Bihar on criminal legislators and on election violence. Bihar is the place where the pattern runs deepest, has the oldest roots and is easiest to see. That is why it is worth understanding. It is not a reason to condescend to it.
Cracks or plaster
This series set out to explain Bihar, not to predict it. Its argument is simple to state and hard to escape. Where land is scarce and industry absent, respect cannot be earned, so it is claimed. The attention of the powerful becomes the scarcest currency, politics becomes its market, and an ancient, plural philosophy supplies a shelter for every compromise the market demands.
Nothing in this picture requires bad people. It requires only intelligent ones, doing what intelligent people do under constraint. The farmer who invokes fate against his brother, the voter who forgives his own strongman, and the leader who breaks a vow he once swore on his life all draw on the same inheritance. That is why the pattern holds: no one is left to cast the first stone, and the first to put down his own pays for it alone.
Yet an equilibrium is not a destiny. It is a balance held in place by its conditions, and the record already shows some of those conditions stirring. Whether the stirrings are cracks in the lock or fresh plaster on it is a question the past cannot answer.
Maithili Sharan Gupt’s Yashodhara could only wait for the man who walked away from her in the night. Her granddaughters no longer wait. They queue, at the polling booth, in larger numbers than the men. What they, and Bihar, do next is where our next series begins.
Author’s Note: This article was conceptualized, researched, and outlined by the author, with generative AI tools utilized to assist in drafting and refining the prose.
References
- The Week, Samrat Choudhary takes oath as Bihar gets its first BJP chief minister
- Patna Press, Samrat Choudhary revives the Janata Darbar
- Bihar Prabha, Government disposes of less than 10 per cent of Janata Darbar complaints (RTI)
- Peter Ekeh, “Colonialism and the Two Publics in Africa: A Theoretical Statement,” Comparative Studies in Society and History (1975)
- Mancur Olson, The Logic of Collective Action (1965)
- Albert O. Hirschman, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty (1970)
- Onmanorama, Nitish preferred death over truck with BJP
- ADR, RJD’s 2020 reasons for fielding Anant Singh
- ADR, Party-wise serious criminal cases among 2025 winners
- Scroll via ADR, Jan Suraaj’s by-election candidates and why voters support criminal politicians
- Mid-day (PTI), Biharis working in other states and abroad
- ThePrint, The Bandyopadhyay Commission report shelved in 2008
- Caravan, Women panchayat officials and proxy candidates
- Deccan Herald, Krishnaiah’s widow moves the Supreme Court
- The Quint, Liquor ban: women, not men, are in high spirits
- Hindustan Times, 11 of 20 strongmen and their relatives make it to the House
- Scroll, 53% of newly elected MLAs face criminal charges, down from 68%
- Deccan Chronicle, No voting-day deaths or re-polling for first time
- The Statesman, How the lot of women has changed (NFHS-6)
- Suman Chakrabarti and colleagues, Effects of a large-scale alcohol ban in India, The Lancet Regional Health: Southeast Asia (2024)
- Deccan Herald, ADR: 45% of 4,092 MLAs face criminal charges
- Maithili Sharan Gupt, Yashodhara (1932)
- Election Commission of India, Bankipur by-election result, August 2026
- ThePrint (PTI), Prashant Kishor wins Bankipur, breaks BJP’s three-decade hold
Articles in this series:
-
-
The Puzzle and the Argument | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 1
-
The Short Ladder | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 2
-
The Attention Economy | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 3
-
The Shelters | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 4
-
The Moral Ledger | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 5
-
Two Registers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 6
-
Collateral, Conscience and Kingmakers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 7
-
The Lock | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 8
-
Discover more from Numerons
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.






