The Grammar of Bihar · Part 3 of 8
Why respect in Bihar is claimed rather than earned, and why the attention of the powerful has become the scarcest currency in the state.
The bow
The convoy arrives in a cloud of dust: three SUVs, a few motorcycles, a jeep with loudspeakers. The candidate steps down, and before he says a word about roads or jobs, he does something that every Bihari has seen and no manifesto mentions. He walks to the elders seated on charpais under the neem tree and bends, one by one, to touch their feet.
He does not skip anyone. Not the old Brahmin who taught half the village to read, and not the frail man from the Musahar tola at the village’s edge, whose community the candidate’s own caste has rarely invited to sit beside it. For a moment, the order of the village is turned upside down. The crowd watches. Children are lifted onto shoulders to see. The old man from the tola will tell the story for years.
Nothing material changes hands. The ballot is secret, and the candidate cannot know who keeps faith with the gesture. Yet campaigns across Bihar spend precious hours on exactly this, village after village, because everyone involved understands what is being exchanged. It is not money and it is not a promise. It is esteem, offered publicly by someone who has power to someone who has little. In Bihar, that may be the most valuable thing a candidate can give.
Why should a gesture weigh so much? The answer begins far from any campaign, inside the house.
Born in the house
A Bihari child’s first lesson in politics is not taught in any school. It is absorbed in the courtyard of a joint family, where three or four brothers, their wives and their children live off a common estate, and where nothing about who gets what is ever entirely settled.
The rules of that household are old. Under the Mitakshara tradition of Hindu law that has long governed inheritance in Bihar, a son acquires a share of ancestral property at the moment of his birth, whatever he later does with his life. Standing within the family is assigned rather than earned: by age, by birth order, by which branch of the lineage one belongs to. Anthropologists call this ascribed status, as opposed to achieved status, and in a household where everyone works the same fields, ascription is the only measure available. No one can prove he contributed more. Everyone can point to who he is.
At the centre sits the karta, the head of the family, who controls the estate and settles disputes. His favour is the household’s first scarce resource. A son whose wife the karta likes, a nephew whose schooling he agrees to pay for, a branch whose marriage he arranges with a good family: each has risen a little, and everyone else has noticed. Children learn early that the person who decides is the person to be near, that being noticed is itself a kind of wealth, and that a slight left unanswered will be remembered against you.
The family’s honour, its izzat, works outside the courtyard like collateral. It decides which families will marry their daughters to your sons, who will lend you grain in a bad year and whether your neighbours will help at harvest. One member’s loss of face lowers everyone’s prospects, so defending it is less vanity than prudence. And the comparisons that matter happen at close range. A Bihari villager does not measure himself against a software engineer in Bengaluru. He measures himself against his cousin across the courtyard, where the smallest difference, a pucca room, a motorcycle, a son in government service, can feel enormous.
The men of the house carry an extra burden. Psychologists studying what they call precarious manhood have found that manhood is widely treated as a status that must be won publicly and can be lost, and that threats to it provoke anxiety and aggression. A man who cannot provide what a man is supposed to provide, because the land is too small and the jobs are elsewhere, can at least refuse to be seen giving way. The women of the house, who carry its honour without controlling any of its land, pay for that refusal in ways this essay will not have room to tell.
Why respect cannot wait
There is a comfortable assumption, popularised by Abraham Maslow’s famous pyramid, that people seek respect only after their stomachs are full. On this view, the poor should care about bread and leave status to those who can afford it, and a politics of dignity in a poor state is a kind of distraction.
The evidence says otherwise. When the psychologists Louis Tay and Ed Diener tested Maslow’s ideas against survey data from 123 countries, they found that needs are universal but not strictly ordered: people draw wellbeing from respect even when their basic needs are not yet met. Respect does not wait in line behind food. In a social species it never has. For most of human history, a person’s standing in the group decided whether others would share food with them, defend them, marry into their family or nurse them when they fell ill. Being disregarded could be fatal, and our minds still treat it that way. The epidemiologist Michael Marmot found that among British civil servants, every one of them securely employed and covered by free healthcare, those in the lower grades died younger. Rank mattered beyond income.
Respect also has a peculiar property. A full stomach stays full whatever your neighbour eats, but standing is relative: only a few can be at the top, and every gain for one is a loss for another. Economists call such things positional goods. And, as Freud observed of what he called the narcissism of small differences, rivalry tends to sharpen rather than soften when the people involved are nearly alike. In a village where nearly everyone farms a strip of land and almost no one owns a car, wealth barely separates one family from the next. Rank is what remains to compete over.
So the hunger for respect in Bihar is not vanity, and it is not a luxury indulged by people who should be worrying about something else. It is a rational pursuit of the one resource that still separates a family that will be helped from a family that will be ignored. And like every scarce resource, it has a market.
The scarcest thing in Bihar
In a state where the institutions that should serve everyone serve few, a small number of people control access to almost everything that matters: a job, a police complaint, a hospital bed, a land record corrected, a court date moved. The many who need these things far outnumber the few who can grant them. What becomes scarce, then, is not only money or land. It is the attention of the powerful.
In April 2006, a few months into his first term, Nitish Kumar began holding what he called Janata ke Darbar mein Mukhyamantri, the Chief Minister in the People’s Court. Every week, people from across Bihar queued at his residence to put their grievances to him in person. Reporters described women in tattered clothes, old men who had travelled overnight, petitioners who were barefoot and others so overawed that they could barely speak. At one nine-hour session in 2016, he heard more than a thousand complainants.
Here is the remarkable part. An RTI application found that in the programme’s first two and a half years, only about 16,000 of some 1.68 lakh complaints had been disposed of, less than one in ten. And still they came, year after year, in their thousands. They were not only coming for a solution. They were coming to be heard by the most powerful man in the state, to stand in front of him and be seen. When Samrat Choudhary became chief minister in April 2026, one of his first acts was to revive the darbar.
What the chief minister does on a grand scale, every powerful person in Bihar does on a smaller one: the MLA receiving petitioners in his courtyard each morning, the mukhiya on his verandah, the fixer who sells access to both. Attention is rationed, and so nearness to power becomes a form of status in itself. A man who can say that the MLA knows him by name has acquired something real. The village now brings its problems to him, and in solving a few of them he becomes a small patron in his own right. Attention flows downward like water through a series of tanks, each level drawing standing from the one above.
This is why so many people seem to be competing for so little, and why the competition feels so insecure. There are only so many minutes in a powerful man’s day, and too many people need some of them.
The currency in circulation
Once you see attention as a currency, much of Bihar’s political behaviour stops looking strange. The bow at the start of this essay is one denomination. Presence is another: the politician who comes to your father’s shraddh feast, or sends a car for your daughter’s wedding, has paid you in public, before the people whose opinion of your family matters most. Gifts are a third, like the bags of Chhath offerings described in the first essay, sent by a candidate facing a murder case to every member of every family he hoped to represent. Chhath is the festival on which a Bihari household’s dignity rests, and celebrating it properly costs money many families do not have. That is why such a gift is remembered.
The value of such a payment depends on who makes it. A bow from a nobody is worth little. A bow from a man the whole district fears is worth a great deal, because it says that power has chosen to honour you. The anthropologists Joseph Henrich and Francisco Gil-White distinguish two routes to standing: prestige, which others confer freely for skill or generosity, and dominance, which is extracted through fear. Bihar’s strongmen are masters of converting the second into the first. Mokama’s voters called Anant Singh “Chhote Sarkar,” the little government, because he helped poor families through hard times. The name says everything. Where the real government does not answer, the man who does becomes the government.
Voters are not deceived by this. A 2022 field study of 2,000 voters in Sitamarhi and Muzaffarpur found that people backed candidates with criminal records because they believed such men could get things done, stepping in where the state’s capacity to deliver had failed. Milan Vaishnav’s national research reached the same conclusion: voters generally know about the charges, and back such candidates strategically.
But the currency has to be backed. In 2025, by one count, only 11 of 20 prominent strongmen or their relatives who stood for the assembly won, and the jailed RJD leader Rit Lal Roy lost Danapur by more than 29,000 votes. A gesture that cannot be redeemed for protection or help eventually stops being accepted. That may also help explain why a newcomer who offered Bihar an impressive programme but no proximity to power found so few takers that year.
Esteem by headcount
What individuals seek one bow at a time, groups seek in bulk. In Bihar, the caste is the natural unit of collective esteem: the network that arranges marriages, lends in hard times, settles disputes and remembers insults. When a community feels that power has noticed it, every member stands a little taller. When it feels passed over, every member feels the slight.
Modern Bihar’s politics can be read as a long series of transfers of collective esteem. In 1978, Chief Minister Karpoori Thakur introduced reservations for backward classes, with a separate share for the most backward among them. It was a redistribution of public dignity as much as of jobs, and it has never been forgotten. In 2024 he was awarded the Bharat Ratna, and in October 2025 Narendra Modi chose to open his Bihar campaign by paying tribute at Karpoorigram, Thakur’s village. A prime minister seeking votes began with an act of recognition.
Then came Lalu Prasad Yadav, who became chief minister in March 1990, months before V. P. Singh announced the Mandal Commission’s reservations, and who rode the wave that followed. Bihar’s roads did not improve much under his rule, and its institutions decayed. Yet for millions of backward-caste Biharis, something else changed, something the political scientist Christophe Jaffrelot called India’s silent revolution. One of their own sat in the chief minister’s chair, spoke their idiom, mocked the manners of the old elite and made no apology for any of it. What he redistributed most generously was not land or money. It was the feeling of counting.
The logic has only sharpened since. Kanshi Ram’s slogan, jiski jitni sankhya bhari, uski utni bhagidari, each group’s share in proportion to its numbers, turned esteem into arithmetic. In October 2023, Bihar’s caste survey supplied the arithmetic. Extremely Backward Classes, 112 castes in all, made up 36.01 per cent of the state; backward classes 27.12 per cent, with Yadavs alone at 14.26; Scheduled Castes 19.65; the unreserved castes 15.52. Overnight, communities that had long suspected they were many could point to an official number, and a number is a claim.
The newest group to be counted and courted is the largest of all. Before the 2025 election, more than one crore women received ₹10,000 each under a state scheme. It was delivery, certainly. For many recipients, it may also have been the first time a government had addressed them directly, by name, as persons in their own right.
The residue
Every market leaves a residue, and this one leaves a moral residue. The candidate who bows to the old man from the Musahar tola in daylight may not share a meal with him after dark. The farmer who touches the feet of a man he fears goes home and tells his sons to respect that man. The voter who knows exactly what the strongman has done votes for him anyway, because the strongman answers the phone. The brother who claims his birthright against his own brother still calls himself a dutiful son. Each of them has done what made sense. Each of them now carries a small contradiction between what he believes and what he did.
Contradictions like these do not stay quiet. People need somewhere to put them, some account of the world in which the bow, the vote and the quarrel can sit beside a decent opinion of oneself. Most societies have a few such accounts to offer. Bihar, as it happens, has been producing them for twenty-five centuries.
Author’s Note: This article was conceptualized, researched, and outlined by the author, with generative AI tools utilized to assist in drafting and refining the prose.
References
Campaign observations are the author’s own.
- Louis Tay and Ed Diener, “Needs and Subjective Well-Being Around the World,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2011)
- Michael Marmot and colleagues, the Whitehall studies of British civil servants
- Joseph Vandello and Jennifer Bosson, “Precarious Manhood,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2008)
- Joseph Henrich and Francisco Gil-White, “The Evolution of Prestige,” Evolution and Human Behavior (2001)
- Christophe Jaffrelot, India’s Silent Revolution: The Rise of the Lower Castes in North India (2003)
- Business Standard, Patna durbar: inside the Chief Minister’s public hearings
- Deccan Chronicle, Nitish Kumar hears over 1,000 complaints at nine-hour Janata Darbar
- Bihar Prabha, Government disposes of less than 10 per cent of Janata Darbar complaints (RTI)
- Patna Press, Samrat Choudhary revives the Janata Darbar
- Ideas for India, When criminality begets crime: the role of elected politicians
- Scroll via ADR, Bihar elections: why voters support criminal politicians
- Milan Vaishnav, Carnegie Endowment, Why India’s electorate votes for politicians with criminal records
- Hindustan Times, 11 of 20 strongmen and their relatives make it to the House
- Deccan Herald, Modi opens his Bihar campaign at Karpoorigram
- News on AIR, Bihar releases the findings of its caste survey
- Outlook, How women voters became a decisive force
- Mainstream Weekly, Lalu Prasad elected chief minister on 10 March 1990.
Articles in this series:
-
-
The Puzzle and the Argument | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 1
-
The Short Ladder | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 2
-
The Attention Economy | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 3
-
The Shelters | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 4
-
The Moral Ledger | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 5
-
Two Registers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 6
-
Collateral, Conscience and Kingmakers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 7
-
The Lock | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 8
-
Discover more from Numerons
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.







