The Grammar of Bihar · Part 7 of 8
The women who carry the costs, the honour and much of the surviving morality of Bihar’s political order, and who may yet be the ones to break it.
The ghat at dawn
On the last morning of Chhath, before the sun is up, the banks of Bihar’s rivers and ponds fill with women. Many have fasted for some thirty-six hours, without food and without water. They step into the cold water in their best saris, baskets of fruit and thekua balanced on their palms, and they wait, singing, for the first light. When the sun clears the horizon, they offer it water and prayers for the health of their husbands and children. Chhath is the festival that brings Bihar’s migrants home from every city in India, and it rests largely on the endurance of women.
In October 2025, a week before polling began, the ghats became campaign stages. Candidates waded among the worshippers, folded their hands, greeted the fasting women and posed for photographs. One candidate, as we saw earlier in this series, won a seat partly by sending Chhath offerings to every family he hoped to represent. The festival that women carry became a currency that men spend.
That image contains the whole of this essay. Bihar’s women carry the costs of its political order, its honour and much of its surviving morality, while holding almost none of its stakes. And yet, in every assembly election since 2010, they have voted in greater numbers than men.
Collateral
In a society where a family’s izzat secures its marriages, its credit and its standing, honour has to be stored somewhere. In Bihar, as in much of north India, it is stored in women: in their conduct, their mobility, their marriages. Women carry the family’s honour without owning it, and they are watched accordingly. A son who strays damages himself. A daughter who strays damages everyone.
Marriage is where that collateral is spent. A daughter’s wedding is an alliance between families, a public statement of their rank, and in most of Bihar it comes with a dowry that can consume years of a household’s savings. When the payments disappoint, the cost falls on the bride. Bihar recorded 1,143 dowry deaths in 2023, second only to Uttar Pradesh. A study of crime data found that in 2022, more than half of all women murdered in Bihar were killed in connection with dowry. The age of marriage tells the same story more quietly. In the 2019-21 National Family Health Survey, 40.8 per cent of Bihar’s women aged 20 to 24 had been married before eighteen; in the latest round the figure has fallen, but only to 34.6 per cent.
One of the sharpest critiques came from Bihar itself. Bhikhari Thakur, the Bhojpuri playwright and performer of the early twentieth century, wrote Beti Bechwa, a play about fathers who sell their daughters in marriage to older men. His troupe performed it across the Bhojpuri belt. The critique came from inside the culture, in its own language.
The last essays traced how men denied the ordinary routes to standing fight harder to defend what standing they have. The research on precarious manhood helps explain where much of that defence lands. A man who cannot prove himself through a profession or an income can still prove himself by controlling the women of his house. The collateral of the esteem economy is held in women’s bodies, and men who have little else often guard it most fiercely.
Priced out of the land
The birthright that makes every Bihari son a claimant to the ancestral fields was, for most of history, a son’s alone. In 2005, Parliament amended the Hindu Succession Act to make daughters coparceners by birth, with the same rights as their brothers. On paper, a Bihari daughter has been an heir for two decades.
The surveys tell a confusing story. In the 2015-16 National Family Health Survey, about half of Bihar’s women said they owned land alone or jointly with others, one of the highest shares in India. But a joint stake in a family estate is not the same as a share a woman can claim, sell, mortgage or leave to her own children. The economist Bina Agarwal, whose work on women and land across South Asia remains the standard account, documented how often women give up their legal share to keep the goodwill of their brothers.
The reason is the esteem economy again. A married daughter’s natal home, her naihar, is her only insurance against a cruel husband or a hostile household. A daughter who claims her share of her father’s land is seen as tearing the family apart, and she may find the door of her naihar closed to her for good. So the law grants her a right, and the culture prices it beyond her reach. The fields that the brothers quarrel over earlier in this series are often fields their sisters own on paper and have quietly surrendered in practice.
Left behind
When the men of Bihar leave for Delhi, Surat or the Gulf, someone has to stay. Usually it is the women. They raise the children, care for ageing in-laws, manage the remittances when they arrive and the debts when they do not, and in many villages they work the family’s fields as well. They carry the responsibilities of the household head without the authority of one.
Bihar’s folk culture has been singing about this for more than a century. Bhikhari Thakur’s most famous work, Bidesia, tells of a young wife whose husband leaves for Calcutta to earn a living, and who waits, and waits, while he builds another life in the city. The bidesia songs of longing that grew around it are still sung across the Bhojpuri belt. They are the folk record of the great sorting described earlier in this series, told from the side of those who were sorted into staying.
The absence of men also shapes the voting figures that this essay will come to. Analysts routinely point out that part of the gap between women’s and men’s turnout in Bihar exists simply because so many men are away on polling day. Women are not only the ones left behind in the household. They are increasingly the ones left behind in the electorate, and so the ones whose votes decide who governs.
The shelters they were offered
An earlier essay described the shelters that Bihar’s philosophical inheritance offers its people: impermanence, destiny, many-sidedness, worldly realism, the emergency clause of apaddharma. Look again at who gets to use them. A man who switches sides can invoke changing circumstances. A man who fights his brother can invoke fate. A man who backs a strongman can invoke worldly realism. The women of Bihar are offered a narrower set: karma that must be endured, sacrifice that must be made, devotion to a husband that must not waver. Men inherited the full toolkit of flexibility. Women inherited the expectation of constancy.
Bihar’s own sacred memory shows the pattern again and again. Sita, the most revered daughter of Mithila, endures exile, captivity and an ordeal by fire, and is then abandoned by Rama to protect his reputation from public gossip. It is hard to imagine a starker image of the esteem economy: a woman sacrificed to keep a man’s izzat intact. In King Janaka’s court in Videha, the philosopher Gargi pressed the sage Yajnavalkya with questions until he warned her that her head would fall off if she went further. And when the Buddha’s foster mother, Mahapajapati Gotami, walked with other women to Vaishali to ask that women be allowed to join his order, they were admitted only under eight special rules that placed every nun beneath every monk.
Yet the tradition also preserved women’s own voices, and they are startling. The Therigatha, the verses of the early Buddhist nuns, is among the oldest collections of women’s poetry in the world. In it, a nun named Mutta rejoices at being free of three crooked things: her mortar, her pestle and her crooked husband. Ambapali, the celebrated courtesan of Vaishali who became a nun, describes the decay of her once-admired body as a lesson in impermanence, the same lesson that men would later bend into an excuse for switching sides. The women took the philosophy seriously. It was the men who took only the comfort.
The Chhath fast belongs here too. It is moral labour of the most demanding kind: thirty-six hours without food or water, performed for the wellbeing of others. It is also, unmistakably, a shelter of endurance. It gives women a sacred role, an arena of dignity and a place at the centre of their family’s spiritual life, while asking them to give rather than to claim.
Keepers of the conscience
The first essay in this series argued that Bihar has not lost its moral anchor, only moored it in a different harbour: in kin and community rather than in the state. Look closely at who holds that anchor, and it is very often a woman. She keeps the fast, keeps the accounts, keeps the household’s rituals and keeps its children in school while the men are away. When the household’s ethics are tested, she is usually the one standing in the way.
The clearest case of women turning that private conscience into public policy is the liquor ban. On 9 July 2015, four months before the assembly election, Nitish Kumar addressed some two thousand women from self-help groups at a state conference in Patna’s S K Memorial Hall. He had barely sat down when a woman in the audience called out: Mukhyamantri ji, sharab band karaiye, ghar barbad ho raha hai, Chief Minister, please ban liquor, our homes are being ruined. Others joined the chorus. Women across rural Bihar, many of them Dalit and backward-caste, had been campaigning against village liquor shops for years. Nitish rose and promised that if he returned to power, liquor would be banned. In April 2016, Bihar went dry. The ban has had real costs: deaths from illicit liquor, mass arrests that fell heavily on the poor, and a thriving black market. But a study published in The Lancet Regional Health: Southeast Asia in 2024, comparing Bihar with neighbouring states, estimated that the ban prevented about 2.1 million cases of intimate partner violence and led to sharp falls in the emotional and sexual violence women reported.
This is the one place in our story where a moral demand rose from below, was voiced by women as women, and reshaped the state. It is worth noticing how unusual that is. Almost everything else in this series has run the other way: private compromises becoming public licence. Here, for once, a private conscience became public law.
Kingmakers
For most of independent India’s history, Bihar’s women voted far less than its men. In 1990, the year Lalu Prasad came to power, about 53 per cent of women voted against nearly 70 per cent of men. Then the gap closed and reversed. In 2010, for the first time, women out-voted men, 54.49 per cent to 51.12. In 2015 the gap widened to seven points. In 2025 women turned out at 71.6 per cent against 62.8 per cent for men; they made up 47.2 per cent of the electorate but cast 50.4 per cent of the votes.
Part of the explanation is the absence of migrant men. But part is that, for the first time, governments began courting women directly, as women rather than as members of their husbands’ households. In 2006 Bihar became the first state to reserve half of all panchayat seats for women. More than 9.7 million bicycles were given to schoolgirls. Women were given 35 per cent of police jobs, and today about 23.66 per cent of Bihar’s constables are women, the highest share in India. The Jeevika self-help network grew to more than 1.28 crore members. In the 2025 election, the Election Commission itself deployed about 1.8 lakh Jeevika members as volunteers. And just before the vote, more than one crore women received ₹10,000 each.
That last transfer depended on something easy to overlook. In 2015-16, about a quarter of Bihar’s women had a bank account they themselves used. By the latest National Family Health Survey, the figure is above 90 per cent. Money now reaches women directly, without passing through a husband’s hands, and that changes what a woman owes to whom.
The result is a constituency unlike any other in Bihar’s politics: one defined neither by caste nor by lineage. The CSDS-Lokniti post-poll survey found that among upper-caste, Kurmi, Koeri, Dalit and Extremely Backward Class voters alike, more women than men leaned towards Nitish Kumar. In a political culture where nearly everything is organised by caste, women had begun, at least partly, to vote as women.
Absorbed
And yet, at almost every point where women have gained ground, the old order has found a way to take it back in a new form. When half of all panchayat posts were reserved for women in 2006, a new figure appeared in Bihar’s villages: the mukhiya-pati, the husband of the elected woman, who attends the meetings, signs the files and is addressed as the real head of the village. One of them told a reporter, laughing, that madam had all the powers and he was merely her PA. The practice is now common enough that a committee of the Union panchayati raj ministry recommended exemplary penalties against it in 2025.
In the assembly, the gap between women’s votes and women’s power is stark. Women cast more than half of the votes in 2025 and won 29 of the 243 seats, 12 per cent. Parties pursue women as voters with schemes and transfers, and hesitate to trust them as candidates.
Even the rolls bent against them. The special intensive revision of the voter list that preceded the election removed about 22.7 lakh women and 15.3 lakh men. In Supaul district, nearly three-quarters of those deleted from the draft roll were women. The largest and most decisive bloc in the electorate was also the one most likely to find itself erased from it.
This is the pattern this series keeps returning to. Women’s gains have been real: more votes, more money in their own accounts, a liquor ban they demanded and won. But the system has repeatedly converted their agency into something it can manage. A seat becomes a proxy. A vote becomes gratitude for a transfer. A bloc becomes a constituency for the same men who ran things before.
The question women raise
If any group in Bihar had reason to break the pattern this series has described, it is women. They bear its costs at every link: the scarcity, the guarded honour, the land they cannot claim, the shelters of endurance, the household left behind. They hold most of what remains of its moral anchor. They have shown, in the liquor ban, that they can turn a private conscience into public law. And they now cast more votes than men.
Yet the pattern holds. Their quota became a husband’s office, their vote became a constituency for familiar men, and their names fell off the rolls in greater numbers. That raises the deepest question of all, the one this series must finally confront. If the people with the most reason to break Bihar’s political order have not yet broken it, what is holding it together?
Author’s Note: This article was conceptualized, researched, and outlined by the author, with generative AI tools utilized to assist in drafting and refining the prose.
References
Campaign observations are the author’s own.
- The Wire, How Chhath Puja became a political stage for the Bihar elections
- ThePrint, Dowry crimes rose 14% in 2023 (NCRB)
- The India Forum, Dowry murders: lingering tragedy, emerging hope
- Scroll, Child marriage in NFHS-5 and NFHS-6
- Bhikhari Thakur, Beti Bechwa and Bidesia
- Scroll, Women’s land ownership in the NFHS
- Bina Agarwal, A Field of One’s Own: Gender and Land Rights in South Asia (1994)
- Joseph Vandello and Jennifer Bosson, “Precarious Manhood,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2008)
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, on Gargi and Yajnavalkya
- Vinaya Pitaka, Cullavagga X, on the founding of the order of nuns at Vaishali
- Therigatha, the verses of Mutta and Ambapali
- Government of Bihar, The liquor ban and the July 2015 demand by self-help groups
- The Quint, Liquor ban: women, not men, are in high spirits
- Governance Now, Nitish bows to women and imposes the alcohol ban
- Suman Chakrabarti and colleagues, Effects of a large-scale alcohol ban in India, The Lancet Regional Health: Southeast Asia (2024)
- IANS, Women voters in Bihar since 2010
- The Wire, What explains the historic voter turnout in Bihar
- Business Standard, The votes that built Nitish Kumar’s stronghold
- Open, The She Factor
- The Tribune, How Bihar’s women became kingmakers
- Outlook, How women voters became a decisive force
- Behanbox, Women’s bank accounts in Bihar, NFHS-5
- The Statesman, How the lot of women has changed (NFHS-6)
- Caravan, Women panchayat officials and proxy candidates
- Business Today, Mukhiya patis in Bihar’s panchayats
- Deccan Chronicle, Government panel recommends penalties against proxy participation
- ADR, Analysis of winning candidates, Bihar 2025
- Scroll, Why the exclusion of women voters in Bihar should worry Nitish Kumar
Articles in this series:
-
-
The Puzzle and the Argument | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 1
-
The Short Ladder | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 2
-
The Attention Economy | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 3
-
The Shelters | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 4
-
The Moral Ledger | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 5
-
Two Registers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 6
-
Collateral, Conscience and Kingmakers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 7
-
The Lock | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 8
-
Discover more from Numerons
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.







