The Grammar of Bihar · Part 5 of 8
How parties, alliances, the state, candidates and voters each balance their books, and why the books always balance.
Ten days in Mokama
On 30 October 2025, a week before polling, two campaign convoys met on a road near Tartar village in Mokama, on the Ganga east of Patna. One belonged to the Jan Suraaj candidate. The other belonged to the JD(U)’s candidate, Anant Singh, a five-time MLA whom his constituents call Chhote Sarkar. In the clash that followed, Dularchand Yadav, a 75-year-old supporter of Jan Suraaj, was killed.
Three days later, a team of 150 police officers arrived at Anant Singh’s house before dawn and arrested him in connection with the murder. Within hours, a message attributed to him was circulating on social media, asking the voters of Mokama to deliver him justice on polling day. The next day, a Union minister, Lalan Singh, and the state’s Deputy Chief Minister, Samrat Choudhary, arrived in Mokama to campaign for the jailed candidate. Lalan Singh told the crowd the killing was a conspiracy and that Anant Singh had followed the rule of law. He urged every supporter to fight the election as if he himself were Anant Singh. Within a day, police had filed a case against the minister over a video in which he appeared to urge supporters to keep a few opposition leaders indoors on polling day.
Mokama voted on 6 November. Anant Singh’s main rival was Veena Devi of the RJD, wife of another gangster-turned-politician, Surajbhan Singh. Anant Singh won by 28,206 votes, his sixth win from the seat. In March 2026, the Patna High Court granted him bail. In October, the JD(U) expelled him and his wife for six years, not over the murder case, but for campaigning for a Jan Suraaj candidate in a Legislative Council election and for insulting the party’s leadership. On 30 October, the Supreme Court cancelled his bail and ordered him to surrender by 1 December.
It would be easy to treat Mokama as an aberration, one violent seat in an otherwise peaceful election. It is better understood as a complete specimen. Every actor in Bihar’s political system appears in those ten days: the party that chose the candidate, the alliance that stood by him, the government ministers who campaigned for him, the candidate who cast himself as a victim, and the voters who returned him. Each of them kept a moral ledger, and each ledger balanced.
The party’s ledger
Since 2020, the Supreme Court has required political parties to publish, for every candidate facing criminal cases, the reasons they chose that person and why no one without such cases could be found. The Court was explicit that “winnability” alone is not a reason. The parties comply on paper, and their reasons are worth reading.
In the 2025 Bihar election, parties furnished reasons for 436 of the 612 candidates with criminal cases whose filings the Association for Democratic Reforms examined. The most common reasons were that the candidate is a social worker, or that the cases against him are politically motivated. In 2020, the RJD had defended its choice of Anant Singh, then facing 38 criminal cases, on the grounds that he was more popular than any other candidate in the area. Five years later, the same man was the JD(U)’s candidate. Both of Bihar’s rival camps had vouched for him in writing.
No party stands apart. In the first phase of polling in 2025, serious criminal cases had been declared by 60 per cent of the RJD’s candidates, 56 per cent of the BJP’s, 52 per cent of the Congress’s and 26 per cent of the JD(U)’s. Even Jan Suraaj, which campaigned as the clean alternative to everyone else, had serious cases against 43 per cent of its first-phase candidates.
The psychologist Albert Bandura spent decades studying how people do harmful things without feeling that they have done wrong. He called the process moral disengagement and catalogued its methods. Three of them appear in the parties’ filings almost word for word. Calling a man with a long list of pending cases a social worker is moral justification: the act is recast as serving a higher purpose. Calling the cases politically motivated shifts the blame onto the accuser. And the unspoken reason beneath both, that every other party does the same, diffuses responsibility until no one holds any of it.
The alliance’s ledger
In August 2022, Nitish Kumar broke with the BJP to form a government with the RJD. In January 2023, a day after the BJP announced it would never ally with him again, he told reporters that he would rather die than go back. In February 2023, Amit Shah stood before a rally in West Champaran, called Nitish a turncoat, and declared the party’s doors closed to him forever. He repeated the vow at Nawada that April. That September, Sushil Kumar Modi, once Nitish’s own deputy, said the BJP would not take him back even if he rubbed his nose on the ground.
In January 2024, Nitish returned to the BJP, and the BJP took him back. What is striking is not that a politician broke a vow; politicians everywhere do. It is that both sides, the one who had sworn never to return and the one who had sworn never to readmit him, found it easy to forget at the same moment. Each needed the other, and each had a shelter ready: circumstances had changed, the people’s interest came first, the past was the past.
The opposition kept its own ledger. In 2025, partners in the Mahagathbandhan fielded candidates against each other in about a dozen seats and called the contests friendly fights. A smaller partner, the JMM, walked out of the alliance altogether, accusing it of betrayal. Chirag Paswan, watching from the other camp, put the euphemism in its place: there is no such thing as a friendly fight; either you are friends or you are fighting. Bandura would have recognised the move at once. Renaming an act is often the cheapest way to change how it feels.
The state’s ledger
In December 1994, G. Krishnaiah, the district magistrate of Gopalganj, was dragged from his official car near Muzaffarpur and lynched by a mob. Krishnaiah was a young Dalit officer from what is now Telangana. The politician Anand Mohan Singh was convicted of instigating the killing. A trial court sentenced him to death; the High Court commuted the sentence to life imprisonment.
Bihar’s prison manual contained a clause that barred early release for anyone convicted of murdering a public servant on duty. On 10 April 2023, the state government, then an alliance of the JD(U) and the RJD, amended the manual and removed that clause. Within days, 27 prisoners were ordered released, Anand Mohan among them. The move was widely read as an attempt to win favour with his Rajput community. Krishnaiah’s widow went to the Supreme Court, arguing that the change was against public policy and would demoralise civil servants. In 2025, Anand Mohan’s son Chetan Anand was elected to the assembly on a JD(U) ticket.
This is the most refined form of moral disengagement, and it deserves to be seen clearly. No law was broken. No court was defied. The rule itself was rewritten, so that what had been forbidden became procedure. Bandura’s catalogue includes the displacement of responsibility onto authority, the comfort of saying that one was merely following the rules. When those who write the rules are the ones seeking the comfort, the circle closes. The state did not bend; it reshaped itself, and the people responsible could say, accurately, that everything had been done by the book.
The candidate’s ledger
Return to Mokama. Anant Singh’s account of himself was simple: the murder case against him was a political conspiracy, and the voters should deliver the justice that his enemies had denied him. In a few sentences, the man accused became the man wronged. Bandura called this attribution of blame, in which the accused recasts himself as the injured party and his accusers as the real offenders. It is one of the most effective moves in the catalogue, because it turns a reason for doubt into a reason for loyalty. To vote against him was no longer to judge a crime. It was to side with the conspirators.
The candidate’s ledger has a second column, and it is filled with acts of conspicuous virtue: the bow to every elder, the bag of Chhath offerings delivered to every family, the appearance at every funeral feast. The psychologists Benoît Monin and Dale Miller described a phenomenon they called moral licensing. People who have recently done something visibly good feel freer to do something questionable afterwards. Later research by Daniel Effron and Monin found that observers, too, will sometimes excuse a transgression that follows good deeds. Generosity in public banks moral credit that can be drawn on later.
This is not hypocrisy in any simple sense. Many of these candidates genuinely help the people who come to them, and genuinely believe that the cases against them are the work of rivals. That belief is precisely what makes the ledger balance. A man who sees himself as a protector wrongly persecuted can do almost anything and still sleep. Ajatashatru needed six teachers. The modern candidate needs only a crowd willing to repeat his version of events.
The voter’s ledger
It is tempting to end the story with the politicians and let the voters off as victims. The evidence does not allow it. Voters in Bihar generally know what their candidates are accused of; research across India has found that knowledge of criminal charges is widespread and that voters back such candidates for strategic reasons. The voter’s ledger is kept with open eyes.
Its entries are familiar to anyone who has listened at a tea stall. He is apna aadmi, one of us. They are all the same anyway. At least this one gets things done. The cases are fake, everyone knows how cases are filed. Each sentence is a shelter, and together they allow a decent person to vote for a man he would not want his daughter to marry.
The sharpest evidence comes from how the voter’s judgment bends with loyalty. The 2025 election was fought, above all, on the memory of crime: the NDA’s campaign urged voters to prevent the return of Jungle Raj, and the voters responded with a landslide. Yet the alliance they elected supplies 77 of the assembly’s 102 members facing serious criminal cases. All six members accused of murder belong to it, as do 16 of the 19 accused of attempted murder. A pre-poll survey by People’s Pulse found that supporters of each camp located the problem of crime in the other: NDA supporters feared the return of the RJD years, while opposition supporters complained of rising crime and corruption under the NDA.
A fair reading needs two caveats. The NDA won 202 seats, so it would naturally supply the most members of any kind; measured per seat, the opposition’s winners were more often accused, with 56 per cent of the RJD’s MLAs facing serious cases against 48 per cent of the BJP’s and 27 per cent of the JD(U)’s. And in many seats, as in Mokama, voters had no clean option to choose. Still, the pattern is unmistakable. Crime committed by the other side is remembered as a threat. Crime committed by our side is understood as protection. Psychologists call this motivated moral reasoning: the verdict is reached by loyalty, and the principle is selected afterwards to fit it.
Why the books always balance
Lay the five ledgers side by side and a pattern appears that none of them shows alone. The party fields an accused man because it expects voters to accept him. Voters accept him because every party fields such men, and refusing one changes nothing. Alliances break their vows because they expect to be forgiven. They are forgiven because every alliance has broken vows, so no one is left with clean hands to object. The state rewrites a rule because neither camp will make it costly, and neither camp will, because each may one day need a rule rewritten of its own.
Each actor’s disengagement is the next actor’s licence. That is what makes this an equilibrium rather than a scandal. A scandal has a villain and an outraged public. An equilibrium has neither: everyone is a little complicit, everyone has a shelter, and every account is accepted because every account will one day be needed. No single actor could change it alone without paying a price that the others would not pay with him.
Equilibria are not frozen. The share of Bihar’s MLAs facing criminal cases fell from 68 per cent in 2020 to 53 per cent in 2025, and the election itself passed without a single repoll. But the ledgers still balance, and they balance in a curious way. The voter’s entries are short and plain: one of us, they are all the same, he gets things done. The politician’s entries come with press conferences, legal notices and appeals to a higher cause. The same moral grammar is being spoken in two very different registers. And that raises a question this essay has not answered: why does a voter forgive in a leader what he would never forgive in a neighbour?
Author’s Note: This article was conceptualized, researched, and outlined by the author, with generative AI tools utilized to assist in drafting and refining the prose.
References
- Outlook, Who is Anant Singh, JD(U) candidate arrested in the Mokama murder case
- Deccan Herald, Anant Singh arrested on murder charge
- Deccan Herald, Lalan Singh calls the Mokama violence a conspiracy
- New Kerala (IANS), FIR against Lalan Singh over poll code violation
- Scroll, Anant Kumar Singh, arrested in murder case, wins from Mokama
- Free Press Journal, Anant Singh dismisses the charges as a political conspiracy
- News Arena, Patna High Court grants Anant Singh bail
- Association for Democratic Reforms, Format C7 analysis: reasons for selecting candidates with criminal cases, Bihar 2025
- ADR, RJD’s 2020 reasons for fielding Anant Singh
- Patna Press, ADR analysis of Phase 1 candidates
- Albert Bandura, “Moral Disengagement in the Perpetration of Inhumanities,” Personality and Social Psychology Review (1999)
- Onmanorama, Nitish preferred death over truck with BJP
- NewsBytes, Amit Shah: BJP’s doors closed forever for Nitish Kumar
- The Week, BJP says it won’t take Nitish back even if he begs
- India TV, Mahagathbandhan to have friendly fights on 12 seats
- Free Press Journal, Maha cracks in the Mahagathbandhan
- Swarajya, Chirag Paswan on friendly fights
- Gulf News, Anand Mohan released from Saharsa jail
- Deccan Herald, Krishnaiah’s widow moves the Supreme Court
- NewsClick, Strongmen and their families among the new MLAs
- Benoît Monin and Dale Miller, “Moral Credentials and the Expression of Prejudice,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2001)
- Daniel Effron and Benoît Monin, “Letting People Off the Hook: When Do Good Deeds Excuse Transgressions?” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin (2010)
- Milan Vaishnav, Carnegie Endowment, Why India’s electorate votes for politicians with criminal records
- ADR, Party-wise serious criminal cases among 2025 winners
- ADR, Winners’ criminal cases by party
- The South First, People’s Pulse survey on Bihar’s 2025 election
- Scroll, 53% of newly elected MLAs face criminal charges, down from 68%
- Scroll, Nitish Kumar says he would rather die than ally with BJP again
- The Wire, FIR against Lalan Singh for urging supporters to “lock up” opposition leaders
- Outlook, Supreme Court cancels Anant Singh’s bail
- Devdiscourse (ANI), JD(U) expels Anant Singh and Neelam Devi
Articles in this series:
-
-
The Puzzle and the Argument | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 1
-
The Short Ladder | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 2
-
The Attention Economy | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 3
-
The Shelters | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 4
-
The Moral Ledger | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 5
-
Two Registers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 6
-
Collateral, Conscience and Kingmakers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 7
-
The Lock | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 8
-
Discover more from Numerons
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.







