The Puzzle and the Argument | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 1

The Grammar of Bihar · Part 1 of 8

Why Bihar keeps surprising those who study it, and an argument that explains why. The first of eight essays on Bihar’s political mind.


Bihar Election Puzzle

The verdict that explained nothing

On 14 November 2025, Bihar counted its votes and embarrassed almost everyone who had tried to read it in advance. Most exit polls had given the ruling National Democratic Alliance between 120 and 172 of the 243 seats. It won 202. The Rashtriya Janata Dal won more votes than any other party, about 23 per cent of all ballots cast, and still finished third, with 25 seats. Prashant Kishor, the strategist who had spent a decade helping others win power, contested 238 seats with his own party and did not win a single one.

Look closer and the contradictions multiply. The winning alliance campaigned on a warning: vote for us, or the “Jungle Raj” of the RJD years will return, with its guns, its kidnappings and its contempt for law. Yet in Mokama, the alliance’s own candidate, Anant Singh, was arrested days before polling in connection with the murder of a rival party’s supporter. A Union minister and the Deputy Chief Minister went to campaign for him anyway, and he won from jail by 28,206 votes. By the Election Commission’s measure, this was the cleanest election in Bihar’s history, with no voting-day deaths and not a single repoll. It produced an assembly in which 130 of the 243 members have declared criminal cases against themselves. And women, for centuries the least powerful people in Bihar’s public life, turned out at 71.6 per cent, against 62.8 per cent for men.

At the centre of it all stood a man whose career should have been impossible. In 2022, Nitish Kumar broke with the BJP, and in January 2023 he told reporters he would rather die than go back to it. Amit Shah answered that the BJP’s doors were closed to him forever, and called him a turncoat. By January 2024 the two were partners again, and in November 2025 Nitish took the oath as Chief Minister for a record tenth time. Five months later he left for the Rajya Sabha, and on 15 April 2026, Samrat Choudhary became the first chief minister Bihar had ever had from the BJP.

Any one of these facts could be filed under “Indian politics is complicated.” Together they demand an explanation.


The usual explanations, and what they miss

The commentary that followed reached for familiar tools, and each contains some truth. Caste arithmetic mattered: the alliance stitched together a broad coalition, while the RJD’s Muslim-Yadav core proved too narrow to win on its own. Money mattered: by the time voting began, more than one crore women had received ₹10,000 each under a state scheme. Memory mattered: every rally reminded voters of the lawless years before 2005. And the opposition’s own disarray mattered, with allies fielding candidates against each other in about a dozen seats and calling it a “friendly fight.”

Yet each explanation answers a smaller question than the one Bihar poses. Caste arithmetic tells us who voted together, but not why a community follows a leader through reversal after reversal, or why caste remains the unit of loyalty when its members’ interests plainly diverge. A ₹10,000 transfer explains a swing, but not why it could outweigh unemployment, which voters named as their top concern by a wide margin before the election. The fear of Jungle Raj explains a vote against one past, but not why the same electorate gave the alliance campaigning against that past so many members facing serious criminal charges of its own, among them every one of the six accused of murder.

There is a deeper problem. These accounts describe what moved in 2025; they do not explain why Bihar moves this way, election after election. In 2020, most exit polls predicted an opposition victory, and the NDA scraped through with 125 seats. In 2025 they predicted an NDA win and badly underestimated its size. The errors run in opposite directions, which suggests the trouble is not bad polling. The instruments are measuring the wrong things.


The real puzzle

The usual question is why Bihar is so unpredictable. A better question is why a population this politically engaged behaves in ways that outsiders call opportunistic. Biharis are not apathetic voters who drift to the polls. Politics is argued over at every tea stall; in villages like Raghopur, young men have been seen taking turns reading the newspaper aloud at the chaupal. The state sends dozens of candidates into the civil services every year. And yet the same electorate rewards leaders who break their vows, forgives strongmen, and moves between alliances without visible guilt.

Outsiders usually resolve this contradiction with contempt. Biharis, the story goes, are casteist, corrupt and easily bought. The explanation is lazy, and the evidence is against it. The political scientist Milan Vaishnav, who studied why Indians vote for candidates facing criminal charges, found that voters generally know about those charges and back such candidates anyway, often because of their reputations rather than in spite of them. Whatever else Bihar’s voters are, they are not fools.

There is a stranger contradiction still. This is the land where the Buddha attained enlightenment and where Mahavira was born. In ancient Magadha, thinkers argued about action, fate, duty and desire with a rigour the world still studies. How did the birthplace of two of humanity’s most demanding ethical traditions become a byword for political pragmatism? The usual answer is decline: Bihar forgot its heritage. I want to suggest the opposite. Bihar did not forget its philosophy. It uses it.


Scarcity, esteem and shelter

My answer fits into a single sentence, though it will take more than one essay to earn it. In Bihar, scarcity turns attention into currency, politics into its market, and a plural philosophical inheritance into the shelter that lets leaders and voters alike bear the moral cost of trading in it.

Start with scarcity. Bihar is landlocked, overwhelmingly agrarian and the most densely populated of India’s large states, with little industry to absorb its young. Land that once fed one household is divided among sons, and then among their sons, until a holding that sustained a family no longer sustains a kitchen. In such a place, the ordinary routes to self-respect, a profession, a business, a rising income, are closed to most people. The need for respect does not close with them.

So respect is claimed rather than earned: by birth, by lineage, by caste, by numbers, and above all by closeness to power. The attention of the few people who control access to jobs, police, permits and protection becomes the scarcest good there is. Politics is the market where that attention is traded, through a bow, a gift, a phone call to the police station, a visible appointment, a scheme named after your community. What looks from outside like transactional politics is, from inside, a struggle for esteem in a place where esteem keeps you alive.

Trading in this market makes people act against their own beliefs: compete with a brother over a strip of land, back a man they know is dangerous, abandon a leader they once revered. That leaves a quiet discomfort that has to go somewhere. Here Bihar’s inheritance becomes decisive. The same soil that produced the Buddha’s renunciation also produced the Ajivikas’ fatalism and the Charvakas’ frank materialism. Their descendants carry all of these ideas at once, not as doctrines learned from books but as common sense absorbed from scripture recitals, folk songs and proverbs. Whatever a person has to do, some part of the inheritance can make it bearable.


A bow, a bag, a book and a broken vow

Abstractions are easy to wave away, so consider four small things. The first is a bow. On the campaign trail, I have watched candidates bend to touch the feet of every elder in a village, whatever that elder’s caste. For a few seconds, the man who will soon hold power over the village places his head below theirs. Nobody mistakes the gesture for equality. Everybody understands what it is worth.

The second is a bag. In one constituency, a candidate facing a murder case had bags of offerings for Chhath, Bihar’s most sacred festival, handed to every member of every family. He earned enormous respect, and he won. It would be easy to call this a bribe. It would also be incomplete. A family that can celebrate Chhath properly has kept its dignity for another year, and the man who made that possible has given something no development programme ever does.

The third is a book. Tulsidas’s Ramcharitmanas, recited in countless Bihari homes, says in one place that the world is governed by action, karam pradhan bisva kari rakha, and in another that whatever Ram has ordained will come to pass, hoihi soi jo Ram rachi rakha. Both lines are loved, and both are quoted, though rarely on the same day. Which one a person reaches for tends to depend on whether things have gone well or badly, and on what he has just done.

The fourth is a broken vow, and the remarkable thing about it is not the breaking. Nitish Kumar swore he would rather die than return to the BJP; the BJP swore its doors were closed to him forever. When they reunited, neither paid a price, and the voters handed them a landslide. A bow worth more than a promise, a gift that is not quite a bribe, a scripture that offers opposite comforts, a betrayal everyone agrees to forget: each is a small door into the same house. Behind each door, if you look closely, a woman is usually paying the bill.


Not an indictment

None of this is an indictment of Biharis. Put any intelligent population on scarce land, close its routes to achievement, weaken the state that should settle its disputes, and hand it a rich vocabulary of justification, and it will behave much as Bihar does. Nor is Bihar unique. Much of the Gangetic plain shares the pattern, and other states outdo Bihar on criminal legislators and on election violence. Bihar is simply the place where the pattern runs deepest and has the oldest roots.

Nor have Biharis lost their moral bearings. Watch a woman keep the Chhath fast, or a labourer in Surat send home most of what he earns, and you will not mistake this for a people without ethics. Their morality is fierce at close range. What it has never embraced is the state, which for most of Bihar’s history arrived as a tax collector or not at all. And none of this depends on books. In a state with one of India’s lowest literacy rates, these ideas travel the way they always have, through recitals, songs and sayings, which is exactly why they reach everyone.


Back to the puzzle

Return, then, to November 2025. A party wins the most votes and loses the election. An alliance warns against lawlessness and elects a man from jail. A leader who swore he would rather die than return is welcomed back by those who swore never to have him, and rewarded with a landslide. Read as a list of events, it looks like chaos. Read through scarcity, esteem and shelter, it reads like a sentence in a grammar most observers never learned.

The most uncomfortable thing about that grammar is not that Bihar’s politics is irrational. It is the opposite. Bihar’s voters and leaders may be among the most rational political actors in India, each doing what makes sense under the constraints they face, and each finding, in one of the oldest philosophical inheritances on earth, a way to live with it. A system built by fools can be fixed with better information. A system built by intelligent people, reasoning carefully under scarcity, can only be changed by changing what they are reasoning about.

To see what they are reasoning about, we have to go back to where every Bihari story begins: a piece of land too small to divide, and a family that divides it anyway.


Author’s Note: This article was conceptualized, researched, and outlined by the author, with generative AI tools utilized to assist in drafting and refining the prose.

References

Campaign observations are the author’s own.


Articles in this series:

    1. The Puzzle and the Argument | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 1
    2. The Short Ladder | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 2
    3. The Attention Economy | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 3
    4. The Shelters | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 4
    5. The Moral Ledger | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 5
    6. Two Registers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 6
    7. Collateral, Conscience and Kingmakers | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 7
    8. The Lock | The Grammar of Bihar, Part 8

Discover more from Numerons

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top